Its been 10 months since Roger Epperson gave a FREE authentcitiy review; I bet he wished he did not. What are the chances that the first one out of the gate was a complete disaster?? He keeps proving himself over and over again... as a nonexpert.

A fool paid Roger $15 for his opinion on this Mccartney autograph.  Roger wrote back says that it was NOT AUTNENTiIC!

E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of Autograph Planet to add comments!

Join Autograph Planet


  • Is that a picture of John Lennon when he was a monkey frog? Roger is all over this, wait.......and its signed by Michael Jackson! I'm gonna go ahead and authenticate that so everyone can see how good I am at authenticating Michael Jackson! Somebody call an ambulance I'm having a heart attack! Heath...........
  • Cool!

    I can dig it!

  • Shut Up Miles!!!!!

    And Just Love!

  • Just concerned about how garbage like this becomes legitimized and placed into the public marketplace?

    It would seem that the public is deserving of an explanation.

  • The Vandesrhoven despises excessive bickering and discord. In the spirit of ultimate, Godly reconciliation, he offers this little song of Friendship to all of the authenticators at AML, Peace Be With You!!!

  • hahaha the part in bold just seems like he's avoiding something. He is a collector himself he knows that resale value goes up if you have a trusted third party cert. I also know exactly why he did this he was testing you roger, to see if you knew your stuff! No need to question why.........
  • Reply by roger epperson yesterday (Sunday Oct 18, 2015)
    Don't worry about it, I'm sure he has been told before that this did not look right, that is why he is searching for an authenticator that will.  I don't understand why someone would pay for an opinion if they get it themselves.  If they were looking for a full LOA I understand but not an opinion.  This was some kind of "fool the expert" game that he wanted to play then post it on this site.  Like I said before, rarely is the first hump not the tallest of the three.  And yes they are sometimes equal but that still makes the first hump the tallest point on the "M", it usually is not lower then the others. 

    Would anybody like to talk about this?

    The highlighted bold part of this?

    Why would anybody who got a autograph in person, want to run it by a authenticator???  Well, with all these "sticker" collectors out there, what do you expect?  With all these people that will only buy things if one of these people from the unregulated, and uneducated industry of 3rd party authentication, what is to be expected?  This nonsence of I am not a self appointed expert, my friends and peers call me one, will be tossed out of court in record time.  Just because somebody else does that does not make it factual!  One self appointed expert calling another self appointed expert a expert is just laughable, and will be seen as just that.  You have the responsibility to correct somebody when they call you that.  Just because people called my Grandfather "Doc" didn't make him a doctor.  He would be the first one to tell you, "I am not a Doctor"

    Now I would like to know, what was this compared to?  How many examples did you compare this to? The 20-25 that you suggested before?  The timeframe?  Did you compare this to a 2015 example?  Or a 1987 example?
      If so, wouldn't it be different?  Don't signatures change over time?  Nobody signs the same way for 50+ years do they?  (Jerry Lee Lewis comes to mind)

    Paul's autograph looks the same today as it did in the 60's?  70s? 80's? 

    Once you found out (saw the photos from the person) and "reversed" your "EXPERT" opinion, how often do you do that?  Was that a one time deal? Do you "flip flop" a lot?  Do you Reverse this self appointed "expert opinion often?

    Again, for the autograph community, just curious.  After all, you say you are the expert.  You should be able to answer these and many more questions like it  about this event.

    Thankfully, this just happened, and it was on a public forum, so it can be part of the upcoming deposition that you will be subject to.  The first of many from the looks of it!  This is just one event, and look at how many questions a person can get from just this?  I'm just a guy from the foothills in  France and I can think of at least 30 different questions, and you can see how easy it is to get him fired up.  Roger is going to be screaming and arms raising and shaking because somebody is questioning one of his MANY mistakes!  It will make for MUST SEE VIEWING!!!

  • Seems like pretty soon Rogers certs are going to be worth less then the breath mints.........I might go with the breath mints?
  • oh by the way......I would have called this authentic. The problem is if I said it on AML I prolly would have gotten bashed for it lol!
  • I know when I sign my name I add an extra loop sometimes at high speeds etc. Maybe even an extra hump or two!
This reply was deleted.